Why the Contractor Matters More Than the Material
The best fiber cement in the world fails when installed wrong — no flashing, tight clearances, skipped wrap. Mid-grade vinyl installed perfectly outlasts premium panels installed sloppily. Siding is a system, and the crew determines whether the system works. Choosing the contractor is the decision; choosing the material is secondary.
Questions That Separate Pros From Pretenders
- "Do you tear off the old siding?" The answer must be yes. Siding over old siding hides rot and skips the wrap. Any contractor who proposes overlay as the default is cutting the corner that matters most.
- "What do you do when you find rotted sheathing?" Listen for a per-sheet rate and a photo-documentation process. Vague answers mean surprise change orders later.
- "How do you flash windows and doors?" You want to hear "metal flashing integrated with the house wrap." If the answer is "we caulk everything," walk away. Caulk is maintenance; flashing is construction.
- "How do you handle vinyl expansion?" (If quoting vinyl.) The answer: nails centered in slots, left loose enough for panels to slide. If they look confused, they have been nailing vinyl tight and buckling walls.
- "What is your clearances spec for fiber cement?" (If quoting fiber cement.) Six inches above grade, flashed butt joints, primed cut edges. These are manufacturer requirements, not preferences.
- "Can I see a job you finished two-plus years ago?" New work always looks good. Two-year-old work shows whether the details held.
Red Flags
- Door-to-door after a storm. Storm chasers flood in after every big weather event. Some are legitimate; many are not. A local company with a local address and local references is always safer.
- Demanding full payment upfront. A deposit (typically 25–35%) is normal. Full payment before work starts is not.
- No written scope. "We will do your siding for a flat fee" without specifying materials, tear-off, wrap, trim, and warranty is not a quote — it is a number. Disputes live in the unspecified details.
- Pressure tactics. "This price is only good today" is a sales technique, not a business necessity. Material prices do not change overnight.
- No proof of insurance. Ask for a certificate of insurance naming you as certificate holder. If they cannot produce one, they do not have it.
The Quote Should Tell a Story
A good siding quote reads like a project plan: exact materials (brand, line, thickness or profile), tear-off and disposal, house wrap spec, sheathing repair rate, flashing approach, trim scope itemized, soffit/fascia status, cleanup plan, payment schedule, start window, and warranty terms for both materials and labor. If you have to ask what is included, the quote is incomplete.
Labor Warranty vs. Material Warranty
These are separate and both matter. Material warranties come from the manufacturer (25 years to lifetime depending on product). Labor warranties come from the contractor — and a labor warranty is only as good as the company behind it. A "lifetime labor warranty" from a company founded last year is worth less than a 5-year warranty from a company with a decade of local jobs you can drive past.
Send the form and put us through this vetting. Ask the hard questions — we welcome them.